A new analysis of ten years of pupil data from Preston Lodge High School has revealed that young people involved in the school’s pipe band programme achieve significantly higher academic outcomes than their peers — both locally and across Scotland. The findings add weight to growing evidence that music education, and pipe bands in particular, play a powerful role in improving attainment, wellbeing and social belonging.
The study shows that 52% of pipe band pupils attained five or more Highers, compared with 39% nationally and 27% across Preston Lodge’s full cohort . Pipe band members were also more likely to leave school with advanced qualifications: 41% achieved one or more Advanced Highers, far exceeding the national average of 18.7% .
The impact was even more pronounced for pupils from Scotland’s most deprived communities. Among those in SIMD quintiles 1 and 2:
45% achieved three or more Highers, compared with 38.2% nationally
40% attained one or more Advanced Highers, compared with 10.5% nationally
These results suggest that pipe band participation may help close Scotland’s widening attainment gap — offering a structured, motivating and socially connected environment where young people can thrive.
The report highlights the distinctive role pipe bands play in school life. As one pupil described, the band is “a friendship group, a learning experience, a safe space and support network… and a self‑discipline builder” .
Head Teacher Gavin Clark emphasised the scale of the impact, stating: “The impact of the school’s three pipe bands is impossible to over‑estimate.”
Pipe bands bring together pupils of different ages, backgrounds and abilities — creating a rare multi‑generational learning environment within schools. This sense of shared identity and purpose strengthens confidence, resilience and teamwork, while offering young people a place they “fit in” and can connect with inspirational peers.
Gavin Clark, Head Teacher
The findings come at a time when access to music tuition is under pressure across Scotland. According to the 2024 IMS survey, only three local authorities can currently provide lessons to all interested pupils, down from five the previous year. Instructor numbers have grown more slowly than pupil demand, and full‑time equivalent posts remain 3% lower than in 2013/14 .
Meanwhile, 74% of independent schools have a successful pipe band, compared with less than 15% of state secondary schools — a disparity SSPDT is working to address by prioritising support for schools in the most deprived areas.
Since its inception, SSPDT has invested over £5.5 million in piping and drumming tuition, equipment, events and community development. The charity provides:
Funding for tuition
Equipment loans and purchasing
Events and performance opportunities
Committee development support
Travel assistance for performances
This support is designed to be flexible, locally responsive and rooted in match‑funding principles that empower communities — particularly where parent engagement is lower due to deprivation.
While establishing direct cause‑and‑effect between pipe band participation and attainment is complex, the evidence from Preston Lodge is compelling. As the report notes: “Ultimately for young people to benefit, the opportunity must exist, and importantly, be accessible to all.”
SSPDT will continue championing that opportunity — ensuring that Scotland’s young people can experience the confidence, pride, achievement and community that a school pipe band brings.